The Premier League have revealed that half of the division’s groups have been on the incorrect finish of incorrect choices from video assistant referees (VAR) up to now this season, no aspect extra negatively impacted than Manchester United.
United suffered blunders in two totally different video games and did not profit from a single error – the identical unlucky report as Brentford. The likes of Arsenal and West Ham additionally discovered themselves hampered by VAR mistakes, whereas Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur had been each aided by missed calls.
These verdicts had been decreed by the division’s key match incidents (KMI) panel, which is made up of three former gamers, one Premier League consultant and one determine from the referees’ physique, PGMOL.
As Tony Scholes, the Premier League’s chief soccer officer, proudly informed ESPN, the tally of 13 errors is down from 20 on the identical stage of final season. The typical common delay of a VAR evaluation is 40 seconds – one other lower from final time period’s 71, however Scholes admitted: “We have a protracted technique to go.”
Bournemouth 1-1 Newcastle (25 August 2024)
Dango Ouattara had a 92nd-minute winner wrongly dominated out for handball, leaving Bournemouth boss Andoni Iraola to fume: “It is essentially the most pissed off I have been on a touchline.”
West Ham 2-1 Man Utd (27 October 2024)
“No one underestimates the importance and the affect of 1 single error,” Premier League CFO Scholes famous. “We all know that one single error can price golf equipment factors, can price them outcomes, can price managers positions, doubtlessly gamers their place.” Erik ten Hag proved that theory again in October, when Jarrod Bowen defeated Manchester United with an unjust stoppage-time penalty the day earlier than the Dutchman was sacked.
Everton 0-0 Brentford (23 November 2024)
Shortly earlier than half-time of a goalless draw, Christian Norgaard was despatched off for following by way of on goalkeeper Jordan Pickford. Brentford’s Thomas Frank mentioned post-match it was “by no means a pink card” and “there must be extra frequent sense”.
Nottingham Forest 3-2 Southampton (19 January 2025)
Chris Wooden was wrongly deemed to be interfering with play from an offside place when Nikola Milenkovic headed Nottingham Forest right into a short-lived 4-1 lead.
Man Utd 0-3 Tottenham (29 September 2024)
Bruno Fernandes had his pink card in opposition to Spurs overturned, with PGMOL chief Howard Webb admitting it was a “mistake” to so severely punish his excessive deal with on James Maddison after a slip.
Aston Villa 2-2 Crystal Palace (23 November 2024)
Ian Maatsen mistakenly prevented a pink card for denying a transparent goalscoring alternative halfway by way of the second half of Crystal Palace’s journey to the Midlands earlier than Villa nabbed their second equaliser.
Everton 4-0 Wolves (4 December 2024)
Craig Dawson’s second personal purpose on the finish of a one-sided rout ought to have been disallowed because of Abdoulaye Doucoure’s interference in play from an offside place.
Nottingham Forest 2-1 Aston Villa (14 December 2024)
Elliot Anderson was not penalised for tugging down Morgan Rogers within the first half. So as to add insult to injustice, Anderson teed up Anthony Elanga’s stoppage-time winner.
West Ham 1-1 Brighton (21 December 2024)
Pervis Estupinan ought to have been given a straight pink card for critical foul play on the finish of a tetchy draw.
Brighton 0-0 Brentford (27 December 2024)
Brighton ahead Joao Pedro escaped punishment for an tried elbow on Yehor Yarmoliuk. “Whether or not you hit them or not, it is a pink,” Brentford supervisor Thomas Frank seethed post-game, “that is how we perceive the principles.” The KMI panel in the end agreed.
West Ham 0-5 Liverpool (29 December 2024)
Liverpool had been solely 1-0 up when Alexis Mac Allister escaped scrutiny for a foul within the penalty field. Cody Gakpo doubled the guests’ benefit 5 minutes later as a rout unfolded at the London Stadium.
Ipswich 0-2 Brighton (19 January 2025)
Ipswich City defender Wes Burns was deemed to have commited a foul worthy of penalty within the opening 11 minutes earlier than Brighton scored twice within the second half. Joao Pedro wasn’t punished for one more harmful problem on this fixture, however that was judged to be the right determination.
Wolves 0-1 Arsenal (25 January 2025)
Myles Lewis-Skelly’s controversial pink card was eventually overturned on attraction, however not earlier than referee Michael Oliver needed to require police protection at his household residence.
